Our Legacy
Celebrating 175 Years of Faith and Community
In 2025, First Lutheran Church of Stewartsville, NJ, proudly celebrates 175 years of faith, community, and service. Since our founding in 1850, we have been a place of worship, support, and spiritual growth for generations. Through times of joy and challenge, our congregation has remained steadfast in its mission to share God's love and serve others. As we honor our rich history, we also look forward to the future with hope, continuing the legacy of faith that has guided us for over a century and a half. Join us as we commemorate this milestone and give thanks for the many blessings that have shaped our church family.
Our Pastors
We have also been blessed with a rich history of faithful leadership. Each pastor who has served our congregation has played a vital role in shaping our community, guiding us in faith, and leaving a lasting legacy. Their dedication, service, and spiritual leadership have strengthened our church for generations. We honor and remember those who have shepherded us throughout the years.
The Rev. Karol Van Wulfen (2021-Present)
The Rev. John D. Kleist (1979—2021)
The Rev. Roger Burkins (1975—1979)
The Rev. Paul W. Hartline (1950—1974)
The Rev. Robert Carl (1942—1949)
The Rev. Raymond Weider (1938—1941)
The Rev. Paul W. Kapp (1932—1938)
The Rev. Luther R. Haus (1927—1932)
The Rev. J. I. Stonecypher (1923—1926)
The Rev. E. W. Fulper (1910—1922)
The Rev. F. H. Crissman (1907—1910)
The Rev. G. H. Easterday (1905—1907)
The Rev. John O. Yoder (1899—1905)
The Rev. Peter S. Hooper (1897—1905)
The Rev. William E. Frey (1891—1897)
The Rev. Augustus R. Steck (1886—1891)
The Rev. L. H. Geshwin (1885—1886)
The Rev. William Kelley (1877—1885)
The Rev. Peter Reizer (1872—1877)
The Rev. J. R. Sikes (1869—1871)
The Rev. Mathias Sheeleigh (1864—1869)
The Rev. J. H. Barkley (1859—1864)
The Rev. D. M. Henkel (1854—1859)
We give thanks for their service and pray for continued blessings on our church’s future.
